285 views

Over 15,000 photos and growing!


  5 - July - 2016

This Month       Today's Picture       Select a Month

Submit a Picture

Where is My Picture?!

The Queue


Select by   Contributor

Met Name

Met Type

Thin Sections


Recent Comments

Unclassified   contributed by Anonymous   MetBul Link


Roll Overs:     #1   #2   #3   #4    


Click the picture to view larger photos

View all entries for   Meteorite (150)   Anonymous (6)


See below.   unclassified

Anonymous writes:
An unclassified stone found in the U.S.A. in the last year.

The finder of this stone was new to meteorites when he made his discovery. In fact, this was his first "find" after he had been searching for only a few weeks. After a few more weeks of surfing the Internet comparing his find to images of similar-looking meteorites, he was convinced that he needed to contact some professionals at a university. But he quickly became discouraged after being told that his little stone probably wasn't worth the expense that it would cost him to get it classified, and that they were not interested anyway if it was an Ordinary Chondrite. The finder, who was a professional but in an unrelated field, was very discouraged to see how disinterested were his counter-parts in the meteoritic discipline with American meteorite finds.

By the time I was contacted by this finder, he had been told by several self-proclaimed "experts" that this specimen was not a meteorite. I explained to the finder that all these problems stem from the fact that there is no funding allocated for the recovery and classification of meteorite found here in the U.S.A. I told the finder that in order to disprove the skeptics and to entice the scientists, he would need to cut a type-specimen from his little stone, and ultimately, to make a thin-section.

The finder soon discovered that his little stone was very badly weathered, because it crumbled into three pieces while being cut. And the thin-section was cheaply made, so admittedly, it is not the best quality. But we feel that we now have enough evidence to dispel the "nay-sayers", and to make a case that this is not an Ordinary Chondrite.

Submitted for your pleasure and opinion. What do you think this "little stone" is?


  Click to view larger photos     #1     #2     #3     #4
 


Comment on this MPOD                      
Name
Comment

980 max length

  Please - NO Dealer Ads in the comments
but pictures from dealers are gladly accepted

Tomorrow

Gold Basin
Twink Monrad

This Month

1 picture in the Queue
Phil Cope
 7/5/2016 7:43:03 PM
My guess would be CR3.? ...
Paul Swartz
 7/5/2016 6:39:34 PM
The contributor, although seemingly shy, is beyond reproach.
Michael Mulgrew
 7/5/2016 4:16:43 PM
Are we sure this isn't a hoax, someone passing off an unclassified NWA CV3 as a USA find? I'm fairly confident I know who the anonymous submitter of this MPOTD is, so that is the only reason my BS flag is only half-staff.
Ben Fisler
 7/5/2016 11:41:09 AM
Glad he continued on the road to classification. I am interested in ALL American meteorites.
Gourgues denis
 7/5/2016 10:59:00 AM
..Like... NWA 1152...CR3.......
M Schulman
 7/5/2016 10:23:52 AM
As others have said, it looks to me like a CV3... CR2 possible? Does it look like it has a good amt. of iron? Nice space rock
Dirk Hohmann
 7/5/2016 6:59:05 AM
I think, it could be a weathered CV!
Gourgues denis
 7/5/2016 5:02:51 AM
......CR2......... ?
Graham
 7/5/2016 4:32:19 AM
Looks possibly carbonaceous to me...perhaps a CV3...possibly some CAIs in there, but well stained due to weathering...
 

Hosted by
Tucson Meteorites
Server date and time
4/19/2024 5:51:49 AM
Last revised
03/29/24
Terms of Use Unsubscribe